Tampa Insurance Disputes Lawyer

What Are Insurance Disputes?

For more than 35 years, Hancock Injury Attorneys has represented clients throughout Florida who were treated unfairly by their carriers. We handle these coverage fights in many forms, including:

• Auto carriers failing to obtain a client's written waiver of uninsured motorist coverage as required by statute, opening up a recovery the client never knew existed
• A company refusing to pay or reimburse an expense that was clearly covered under the insurance policy
• A carrier denying or undervaluing diminished value claims after a vehicle has been repaired following a crash
• Subjecting the insured to unreasonable and extreme demands simply to process a routine file
• Refusing to settle a claim brought against one of the company's own policyholders, including fights over settling a claim for a minor child
• Failing to settle within the defendant's policy limits, exposing the policyholder to personal liability — including liability for loss-of-consortium damages
• Claim battles where your treating doctor is now seeking full payment directly from you, along with the mounting medical bills that come with it

Types of Insurance Claims and Coverage We Handle

Coverage fights are not limited to one line of insurance. Our insurance lawyers handle a wide range of claim types, because almost every type of insurance can become a battleground when money is on the line. Common categories include:

• Auto insurance — PIP, uninsured/underinsured motorist, bodily injury, and property damage claims after a collision
• Property — homeowner and commercial insurance losses from storms, water, fire, and theft, including property insurance claims the carrier lowballs or stalls
• Health insurance claims — denied treatment, retroactive denials, and surprise billing fights
• Life insurance — beneficiary fights and wrongful refusals, including delayed or contested life insurance claims
• Liability claims — third-party matters where the carrier refuses to defend or indemnify its own insured

These are only the most frequent claim types we see, and they are far from the only types of claims that turn into a fight. Whatever line of coverage is involved, the same pattern repeats: the company looks for a reason to deny or delay rather than pay.

Bad Faith Insurance and Unfair Claims Handling

The Florida Code of Ethics for Insurance Adjusters requires, among other things, that an adjuster handle every adjustment and settlement with honesty and integrity, and never approach an investigation, adjustment, or settlement in a way that is prejudicial to the insured.

Adjusters and insurance agents are also prohibited from dealing directly with a claimant they know to be represented by counsel, from unduly influencing witnesses, from advising a claimant not to seek legal advice, and from knowingly failing to advise a claimant of his or her rights under the contract and the laws of Florida.

Examples of unfair claim settlement practices prohibited by Florida insurance statutes include:

• Failing to adopt and implement reasonable standards for the proper investigation of claims
• Misrepresenting pertinent facts or insurance policy provisions relating to the coverage at issue
• Failing to acknowledge and act promptly on communications about a claim
• Denying claims without conducting a reasonable investigation based on available information
• Refusing to affirm or deny full or partial coverage, or — as to partial coverage — the dollar amount or extent of coverage, or to confirm in writing that the matter is being investigated, upon the insured's written request within 30 days
• Failing to provide a prompt, reasonable written explanation of the policy basis, in relation to the facts or applicable law, when it denies a claim
• Failing to pay personal injury protection (PIP) claims within the time periods Florida law requires

When a company crosses these lines, the conduct can move from a routine disagreement into something the law treats far more seriously. Insurance companies may dress up a refusal as a coverage interpretation, but our bad faith attorneys can evaluate whether you are owed more than your policy limits.

When an Insurance Company Denies a Claim

There is a difference between a claim that is legitimately contested and one the carrier never intended to honor. When an insurance company denies your claim, the denial letter rarely tells the full story. We have handled denied insurance files where the file was rejected over a "missing" document the insured had already sent, and others where the insurance claim has been denied based on a policy exclusion that did not actually apply. Sometimes there was never a valid claim against the coverage at all — and sometimes there plainly was.

A carrier needs a reason to deny a claim, but it does not always need a good one — it is making a business calculation, betting you will not push back. Insurance companies deny far more often than people realize, and an insurance company may deny a perfectly good claim simply because it expects you to give up. So if your insurance claim is denied, do not assume it is final — sometimes the fix is documentation, and sometimes it requires legal action or formal insurance litigation. Either way, understand your options before you accept "no," and before the company can quietly deny coverage and close the file.

5 Tricks Insurance Companies Use After a Crash to Underpay You

Once you understand the adjuster's job, you understand why he or she wants to speak with you. The adjuster wants to take control of your file by getting you to make statements or admissions that work against your own interests — words that will later be used against you. Here are common tactics adjusters use to get claimants to devalue their own cases and help the company avoid paying your claim.

Acting Like the "Good Guy"

The adjuster may act like a friendly neighbor who is on your side. They want you relaxed and comfortable talking about your crash and injuries. They are trained to be "nice," because carriers know they can pull more information out of you with sympathy and courtesy. Your words are then twisted and used against you. Even a polite reply like "I'm fine, Mrs. Smith, how are you?" can show up in a report as "Victim says she is feeling fine."

Getting a Recorded Statement

Adjusters routinely ask accident victims for a recorded statement "just to confirm our insured was at fault." They already know their driver was at fault — they have their own statement and the police report. Questions sometimes come up about filing a claim without a police report and how that affects coverage, but the recorded-statement request is rarely about the facts.

Never give an opposing adjuster any written or oral statement without talking to a lawyer first. Florida law does not require it, and the adjuster's goal is to use your own words against you later, attack your credibility, and imply you are exaggerating. Rather than take that risk, arrange a free consultation and case review with our team before you say a word on the record.

Getting a Medical Authorization

You can also expect a blanket medical authorization to sign and return, and it will feel mandatory. It is not. Do not sign it, and do not return it — just keep it in your file. The adjuster is hunting for a prior injury to the same body part so your current symptoms can be blamed on something that happened 15 years ago.

Saying You Don't Need a Lawyer

Many adjusters tell claimants they "don't need an attorney for this." Sometimes that is true — but you may not have the experience to navigate the legal process successfully on your own. Strong legal representation can dramatically change what you ultimately recover, and we can give you a first-offer analysis before you decide whether to accept the company's proposal. When we believe someone will net more without hiring us, we tell them so — and we still give them the advice they need, for free, to handle it.

Arguing You Got Too Little — or Too Much — Treatment

Adjusters love to argue that your medical care was either excessive or inadequate. It is a double-edged sword: either you are "faking it" and over-treating, or your records "don't show" you followed your doctor's plan. So follow your doctor's recommendations, get the care you actually need, and talk through your treatment with your counsel.

Why Hire a Tampa Insurance Disputes Lawyer for an Insurance Fight?

Insurance companies are not afraid of unrepresented claimants. They are afraid of dispute lawyers in Tampa who understand how carriers actually operate and who are willing to take a file all the way through trial. Major insurers field entire teams of lawyers; you should not face them alone. Our dedicated attorneys do not treat these matters as paperwork — we treat them as the contract fights they are.

Carriers count on delay. Delaying payment lets them hold your money longer while it earns interest for them, and it pressures injured people into accepting less out of sheer exhaustion. An experienced insurance dispute attorney removes that leverage. We document everything, escalate when the law allows, and are prepared to file suit when a company will not deal fairly.

That defense-side work taught our founder which arguments carriers respect and which they ignore. It is the difference between hoping a claim gets paid and putting seasoned litigation attorneys behind it who make sure it does.

FAQs